Well toad, your second comment holds tru. They don't really matter.
It's a nice little thing for fans to argue about on the internet butnot much else.
There are a lot of things that go into recruiting such as need. And type. A coach isn't going to recruit a higher graded "road grader" if a slightly lower rated "zone blocking" lineman is available.
And you never know who was going to go to Michigan or Ohio from the beginning. If a high 4* comes to you a year before and commits and you only need one do you take him or leave him hang and recruit a higher one?
Lots of stuff goes into it.
Plus, I never figured out how they could possible tell me someone was the 120th best player and someone else was the 140th best player. Or to go deeper, don't they have a top 300? So someone knows who is #299 and who would be #301? Riiiiiiight. lol
Off the soapbox
_________________
"What the HELL's going on out here?"